It’s that time of the year again, the time when we get to compare the latest flagship from the big names… before the iPhone arrives and the catch-up and leapfrog cycle starts all over again. Currently in the ring? Samsung’s jumbo Note 9 and Huawei’s triple-threat P20 Pro.
Samsung’s S Pen-packing super phone features a larger screen, improved cameras, and other upgrades to last year’s edition, although by and large, it’s not a huge change from the Galaxy Note 8.
Meanwhile, Huawei’s P20 Pro is our current reigning smartphone champion, standing tall above even Samsung’s Galaxy S9. Does it maintain its title defence against the Galaxy Note 9 as well, or has Samsung’s latest proven to be the smartphone world’s greatest? Here’s how this battle shakes out now that we’ve reviewed the Note 9.
Design — Twilight Forever
All told, it’s a nice looking mega-handset – but we still prefer the Huawei P20 Pro. The P20 Pro has a sleeker build and hand-friendlier size, plus the gradient Twilight colour option is absolutely dreamy. Your call on whether you can deal with the notch or not.
Verdict: Huawei P20 Pro
Screen — Samsung’s Edge
The Huawei P20 Pro’s screen is very impressive, delivering a bright, 6.1in OLED panel with incredible contrast. At 1080p, though, it’s not quite as crisp as some of the other high-end flagships on the market – not that it’s a massive difference.
Even so, the Galaxy Note 9 comes out just ahead. Samsung has reliably served up the best flagship smartphone screens over the last few years, and given that it’s cut from the same cloth as the Galaxy S9, this 6.4in curved Quad HD Super AMOLED panel is another stunner. It’s also 0.1 inch larger than last year’s model, in case you can tell the difference.
Verdict: Samsung Galaxy Note 9
Camera — Go Pro
It’s essentially the same setup as the Galaxy S9+, which was pretty great, although it comes with some AI assistance that tweaks the camera settings based on your surroundings, or even tells you when a snap should be retaken because someone blinked or the lens is dirty. Generally, the AI gets it right, and doesn’t blow out the colours on shots.
On the other hand, the Huawei P20 Pro boasts the best smartphone camera setup on the market, hands-down. It’s a monster, with 40MP RGB, 20MP black-and-white, and 8MP telephoto sensors that combine their talents to do some pretty amazing things.
It’s capable of 3x optical zoom and a 5x “hybrid zoom” that captures surprising detail from afar, and photos tend to look pretty fantastic no matter your lighting. Just consider turning off the Master AI feature here, which can blitz out the colours to an unnatural degree. Samsung has the edge in that regard, at least.
The Galaxy Note 9 certainly has one of the top cameras you’ll find on a flagship today… but the P20 Pro is still better and more flexible.
Verdict: Huawei P20 Pro
Performance — Raw power prevails
The Note 9 has the same chip inside, with either 6GB or 8GB RAM depending on model, and it comes out ahead again. That said, both the P20 Pro and Galaxy S9 are super-speedy phones, so you’re unlikely to notice any difference in day-to-day usage even if you were using them side by side.
Verdict: Samsung Galaxy Note 9
Battery and perks — Note-able benefits
That’s good for a day and a half on the P20 Pro… but surprisingly, the Galaxy Note 9 can’t keep pace. It’ll give you a bit more than a day with moderate usage, but with its larger, higher-resolution screen, it just doesn’t have the endurance of the P20 Pro, especially if you dial the screen res all the way up… and you’re going to want to.
In terms of storage, the Note 9 definitely has a lead here. The P20 Pro just ships with 128GB of internal storage without microSD expandability, while the Note 9 comes in with 128GB and 512GB models – and you can add another 512GB via microSD cards. Huawei must’ve known this criticism was coming, though, as it’s just announced new 256/512GB versions of the P20 Pro for China (along with some new colours).
Both phones offer a PC-like desktop mode with an external monitor, each just needing a USB-C to HDMI cable — no more pricey DeX Pad accessory for Samsung. Meanwhile, the Note 9 also brings Gear VR headset support, which is unmatched by Huawei.
Of course, the Galaxy Note 9’s most unique perk is the S Pen stylus, which this time comes with Bluetooth connectivity. Why? It means you can use it as a remote for snapping photos, playing videos, or controlling presentations, plus it does all of the usual scribbles and notes.
As usual, Samsung packs in plenty of bonus perks that go above and beyond, although you’ll have to have a hard think about whether you actually need a stylus with a smartphone. If not, then you might be better off with the improved battery performance of the P20 Pro.
Verdict: Samsung Galaxy Note 9
Verdict — No upset here
The Samsung Galaxy Note 9 takes more categories in this comparison, but at the end of the day, we can’t help but come back to our overall impression from the Note 8 — it’s super-niche and super expensive, and unless you’re completely set on the stylus, you can get an otherwise just-as-capable phone for far fewer Randelas.
That’s especially true since Note 9 is even pricier than last year’s model, coming in at R19,000 for the base model and around R25,000 for the higher storage/RAM configuration. Apple really opened up the floodgates there, but the Note 9’s lack of big upgrades means that it struggles to live up to the expectations that the price point creates. The P20 Pro, meanwhile, costs a far less terrifying R11,500.
We still think that the P20 Pro is the best all-around handset on the market today, packing the absolute best camera setup and a fabulously eye-catching design. Don’t get us wrong, we like the Note 9 a lot, and productivity mavens who need a stylus already know which phone they want for the job, but for the average phone buyer the Huawei P20 Pro remains the more practical purchase.
Winner: Huawei P20 Pro